Board Thread:Manga/@comment-27321453-20180906211831/@comment-36307699-20180913090826

CaptFredricks wrote: Penguinluver1431 wrote: Tdfern14 wrote: Penguinluver1431 I see no positive development for her even after this chapter, no matter how hard Isayama tries.

Overall, though, much better chapter than most of the Marley arc itself, looks like we're building up for quite the explosive final conflict. Do you think Isayama is a terrible writer? I think he's done much better in the past than what we've been getting this arc. I've made no secret how much I loathe the Marley arc, it was the worst one yet; poorly written and a cheap attempt at Isayama trying to force us to empathize with what is essentially AoT's Nazi Germany. If he wanted us to empathize with the villains, he would have planted those seeds much earlier in the series. Doing it at this point, after showing the crimes Marley has committed against Paridis, it fruitless.

Barring the Warriors from before the time-skip (Reiner, Annie, etc.) the only one I like is Falco. Gabi I despise and want to suffer as gruesomely as possible. The others I am meh about. I'm probably one of the only ones who actually enjoyed watching Marleyans die, so needless to say, I'm a fan of Floch and would like to see Paradis resume its rightful place as the heroes of the story.

But yes, long story short, I think Isayama is slipping as far as his writing nice, but thats mostly the case with a lot of fiction that makes it as far as it has. Interesting you feel this way about the Marley arc. It's currently my second favorite behind the Uprising arc. To each their own, I guess.

This chapter was a solid 9-9.5/10 for me. Loved the callbacks to early in the story with Louise, who Mikasa saved in Trost, and Kaya, who Sasha saved near her hometown. Well I think that the Marley Arc is pretty good. It provides us with understanding about our warriors lifestyle on the other side.

We all assume on what their livelihood is like. Not to mention on wondering that they are truly the enemy because of paradise POV and some titbits/flashbacks.

Now that Isayama created their world from the other side. We've learn about the warriors from their POV that they aren't villains. We now know that they are living in a discriminating lifestyle (due to being Eldians). They live in intermittent zones, separated from ordinary humans because of being Eldians. Plus we've learn that Marley isn't the only ones that discriminate and imprison Eldians within walled-like communities, whole world are doing it. It feels like paradise world but before the uprising.