Board Thread:Manga/@comment-44086949-20191205133131/@comment-25933225-20191206004513

Oh, and by the way, you will never convince me. That wasn't time travel, I explained why. I explained why it's a fixed timeline. The thing you mentionned with Historia receiving memories from touching items is just an anime thing, because they already showed Ymir's flashback, so they just needed a way to show that Historia learned Ymir's backstory.

And... No. PR isn't a physical space. Not at all. Even the wiki call the real world a "physical world", to make the difference between PR which isn't physical, but only a representation of Paths.

Also, no, Eren isn't just mentionning his dad's books. Remember, he wakes up frightened, after receiving the memories of his father watcing Dina being transformed.

About Avengers, that's because you mentionned them first.

About the "source"... I already knew it was a fixed timeline, looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooong before chapter 121. I already knew the concept of fixed timeline since I was a kid, with HP. So, it's my opinion. Supported by many. This source just explains in this paricular case.

About the souls, well even the wiki says Ymir's sool is in the PR. And if it's not their soul (or astral body, whatever you want to call them), what else could it be? Not their bodies, which are still in Shiganshina.

And I don't know why you talk about Eren Kruger, I never mentionned him in the first place.