Board Thread:Manga/@comment-44086949-20191205133131/@comment-44086949-20191206000411

Razzylada wrote: "From Zeke POV, he saw Eren talking to Grisha, and Grisha acted based on this. But he doesn't know Grisha received memories of Eren and was "seeing from Eren POV", that he heard what Eren said because he received his memories."

As I've pointed out before, ATs haven't been shown to give users passive memories without royal blood. He did not and could not have touched Dina after recieving his powers. Even if he could, Dina is a mindless titan. Eren had to touch a concious human in order to recieve memories, as a mindless titan can't control ymir with any commands.

Razzylada wrote: "With the difference that HP used time travel, SnK didn't."

Still nothing to show that what Eren & Zeke did was't literally time travel. Even the source you add at the bottom thinks it's time travel; Their arguments can't be used here because it depends on time travel being used.

Razzylada wrote: "I won't talk about Avengers because I hate superheroes and I never watched these."

...Okay?

Razzylada wrote: "Let's remember that Eren received numerous loooooong memories from his father. And he wasn't able to use the Founding Titan that time, and he wasn't touching a royal blood person."

Those "memories" you speak of were him reciting the book Grisha had in his basement. Also, Historia was able to transfer memories through inanimate objects, so the next plausible thing would be that he got memories from Dina's DNA on the photo/book.

Razzylada wrote: "Where did I say that Paths Realm was a physical place? Nowhere. And I'm perfectly aware that this isn't a physical place."

Typo on my end. I meant to say, '''"the PR is actually a physical place." '''as in it proves that the Paths realm is entirely physical.

Razzylada wrote: "it's only Eren and Zeke's souls (or astral bodies?) that are in the Path realm. Not their physical bodies, which are still in Shiganshina. I understand that two souls can touch each other, but a physical body (Grisha) and a soul?"

Where has this ever been established that A. souls exist, and B. their paths bodies aren't physical? Which B is contradicted by the fact that a non-paths body touched one from the PR.

Razzylada wrote: "And.. EVEN IF all of that weren't just memories but was also time travel... That doesn't change at all the fixed timeline stuff. That's fixed, whatever Eren does, that just make stuff that has already happened happen. Like the Reiss massacre." https://external-preview.redd.it/_yMyuRmwMWmcFaOsxJEUt7RtOfgtEkMSRu2VOtFEnN8.jpg?auto=webp&s=489ba9d4f46a7c28767fd9f49f1123344fdb90e4

Thank you for giving me the source for your "fixed timeline" theory. I would have much rather heard your own opinions though, as I'm not in a position to easily click reddit links.

It's an interesting theory, but it lacks two things. 1.) it assumes that Eren Kruger recieves passive memories from other titan users, despite the fact that he had touched Dina in chapter 87, and 2) it ignores the possibility that Eren knew exactly where and when to interact with the past in a manner that does not change the future, causing the butterfly effect. This can be seen in "A Sound of Thunder," where it depicts a universe where time travel via machine exists, but they follow a direct path and instruction to avoid changing the path. Under these circumstances, they are operating in a fixed timeline, however, one person makes the mistake of walking off the indicated path, stepping on a butterfly. This impacts the timeline as it changes the election results.

Also, the fact Eren can see time simultaneously via the PR, he should be able to make an infinite amount of revisions in his actions to achieve the best result.