Board Thread:Manga/@comment-27321453-20191208140701/@comment-44328804-20191211062404

EthanPHX wrote: Penguinluver1431 wrote:                                                                                                                That's actually not true. I have hated Annie since she was revealed as a Titan. Same for Reiner and Bertolt. Bertolt's death gave me much joy, and hopefully Levi will be able to get revenge for his fallen comrades once he learns Annie is free. And let's be honest, Reiner wants to die, so why not put him out of his manpain, make things a little less angsty emo? What makes Eldia so much greater than Marley? Have you forgotten that for over 1900 years Eldia has been a super power that oppressed and murdered off several different nations? What makes Eren better than Reiner and Bertolt? This whole MURDER BAD mindset you have in your head is really ignorant for the type of series this is. Did Reiner and Bertolt chose to breach Wall Maria? No. They were forced by Marley and fed lies as children. They did what they had to do in order to protect themselves and their families, believing they would be set free if their mission was complete. Eren CHOSE to massacre several thousands of civilians and you don't see anyone talking about that now do you? I like both the warriors and Eren, and I can objectively say you sound like a warrior fanboy. Not that I entirely agree with Peguinluver, but how you say the warriors didn't choose to breach the wall when they did and how Eren "CHOSE" to do what he did when he truly had no choice makes you look like very uncredible here. Honestly, you should reread Reiner's confession in chp 100 if you truly think he is completely absolved, yet think Eren is a "villain" who chose to do something horrible. Also, ur right that Eldia started the war a long time ago, but now in Eren's time, Marley is the wrong one.

Do I think they are both forgivable? Of course. Ultimately they were both forced into fucked up situations, and had no choice but to do bad things. Just like how the warriors didn't turn out to be villains when they looked like it, Eren will no doubt turn out the same way with no doubts. Villain was always the wrong term for him anyway. Eren is much a villain as the warriors. If they did nothing wrong, he did nothing wrong. If he is evil, then they are evil too. You either validate both or none.