User blog comment:XGlass Reflection/Episode 5 Review~ DON'T HEADBUTT A LADY!!/@comment-123.231.120.106-20130508170111

Firstly, I'm not an anon, I simply logged out cause I don't wanna be part of wikia I simply visit for the sake of gaining knowldge and not edit.

I'm like in chapter 40 in the manga(and I read all the wiki articles), and I'm still mindfucked about this series. It makes no fucking sense, its awesome alright but the writing is extremely half-baked.

My first problem, the motive behind shape-shifters. The whole Reiner,Bert betrayal  thing makes no sense. How could they be at two places at once. The Colassal titan appeared first and broke the first wall, then somehow, Ymir(who is apparently worshipped by titans) killed and ate villagers in front of Reiner and Bert. If those two intended to destroy humanity from the start then why the fuck did they feel sadness at the loss of their families? It makes no bloody sense unless of course they really do forget everything when after Titan mode and especially at that age. Still lots of questions there.

How many of you think that Titans and humans aren't two different species? Looks to me like this is some serious conspiracy series, where the original introduction given at the beginning of the series was completely false. What if the original people that built the wall, built it to protect the "pure" humans that couldn't turn into titans? What if the world outside the wall is in fact still having regular civilizations and only this certain population of humans is under attack? So far everything this series has stated has been broken. We are still to get any concrete idea about anything. For all we know the humans could be titans that have forgotten who they are, and the shock from realizing, makes them go berserk or maybe they become like zombies or hollows(Bleach) and feel a deep urge to devour everything human.

Another thing is the nape of the neck, if all titans have that in common it is probable that in all titans there is someone riding in it, but then, how come they never discovered anything when they sliced open their necks? and what happens to the human body inside? surely it doesn't just disappear. Here is where the theory I have comes in again. If the human truly merged with the titan and lost the ability to think outside if its gut instinct then the body probably no longer exists.

In the end this series would turn out to be something completely different from what we originally started with. In this way, how is it any different from the series you guys claim to hate? Can you name any of the top ongoing or finished action series that remained true to the original plot-line?

I'm sorry if this comes as a rant but this series has too many plot-holes in it to warrant an anime. Generally when I watch an anime, I read the manga to get some answers, well I read the manga, but my questions are still unanswered.