Board Thread:Manga/@comment-30064439-20161025230340/@comment-30064439-20161103234255

1. Eren and Historia have objectively more chemistry than any other set of characters in AoT. Throughout the course of the latest arc they have shown the most growth between them relationship-wise than any other duo. So it’s not only the pairing with the most chemistry and the best dynamic but also the most developed pairing

2. Ymir is not abusive but she doesn’t treat Historia in the best way; lying, manipulating, being secretive.

3. Historia has never shown romantic attraction towards Ymir. You people can’t seem to grasp the idea of a mere close friendship between two females. I think the reason for why they’re shipped so much is because of Ymir being canonically gay

4. Ymir being canonically gay and in love with Historia doesn’t have to mean that Historia likes her back. Refer back to point 3; Historia has never thrown hints that she likes Ymir romantically. I have read all their interactions, I have analyzed every single one of them, while it’s clear that Ymir is in love with her, on Historia’s side it is unclear whether she likes Ymir back or not

5. Historia has thrown hints that she may be developing feelings for Eren- I’m not claiming that it’s 100% certain that she does hold feelings for Eren. However, listen up, she blushed, smiled and avoided his gaze right after Eren told her that she was a great person. Furthermore, her blush only deepened when Eren started teasing her about her behavior in the cave. Her manners are typical of a girl who has a crush on the guy interacting with her.

6. Mikasa’s obvious jealousy when confronting Eren and Historia. Mikasa senses that there’s something up between them, or at least she notices that Historia could form a threat. written by http://historia-is-in-love-with-er-blog.tumblr.com/ i totally agree with this.



7. The pairing of Ymir and Historia is not canon, it was a mistranslation. I could refer you to the post if you want

8. Extra material doesn’t count as manga-canon. They pander to Yumikuri because Yumikuri is a widely liked pairing. Isayama approving of the extra material doesn’t automatically make it canon. Isayama simply wants money, he would approve of anything that gives him more money

Here, I am done.