Talk:Porco Galliard

Porco's Titan Candidacy
As of right now, it is currently unknown exactly why Porco was chosen as a Warrior candidate. In Chapter 94, it only shows that Marcel was chosen because of his speed, not Porco. With this, it is inaccurate to say that Porco was chosen for the same reason. I would change the information myself but I do not know how to edit reference links. JustAlex94 (talk) 14:03, June 17, 2017 (UTC)

Can you quote the section bothering you? The only reference I see to his speed involves his Titan powers, and that has nothing to do with Chapter 94. The line involving his warrior candidacy is: "He and his brother Marcel were chosen to be candidates for warriors after an extenuating physical test involving running under the rain with military equipment" which does not mention a specific reason for why he was selected other than he passed a test, which is true of all the warriors.RuneLai (talk) 20:12, June 17, 2017 (UTC)

That line, along with the line "Just like his brother, Galliard is in a very good shape, being able to pass an arduous physical test designed to identify possible Eldian warriors." under his Abilities section. At this point, we don't really know anything about how the tests are graded. The chapter seemed to imply that each test had only one passing person. After reading your post, I see that the line "He an his brother Marcel..." can stay exactly the same, but I would change the latter line, "Just like his brother..." to "Galliard is in very good shape, and his overall abilities make him strong enough to be an Eldian Warriors" My reasoning is that it seems that the Warriors are chosen individually, so his abilities don't necessarily coincide with Marcel's, and at this point we can't say for certain that Marcel wasn't the only one to pass the physical fitness test. JustAlex94 (talk) 08:25, June 18, 2017 (UTC)

Okay, I can see that. We don't know how Porco compared to his brother in physical shape. It's a minor text tweak so I went ahead and made it and adjusted the reference link. RuneLai (talk) 16:54, June 18, 2017 (UTC)