Board Thread:Manga/@comment-27321453-20180208183201/@comment-28958062-20180220152708

Arshpar wrote: Well, if it were about a world dominated by titans, the story would've been pretty short, how long would it take to spread to dominate the world by killing mindless beasts? With the current look of the SC, i think that story would've ended in a chapter.

This has lot of plotholes, similarities to other mangas, but honestly, i want to delve into AoT more than any other manga, even more than a masterpiece like Tokyo Ghoul! Why? Because when we read, we imagine ourselves as people searching for freedom too. Honestly it ain't mediocre, we've to credit Isayama for bringing up a first in it's kind storyline. We see characters who have worst lives, people who lose dear things, but also bonds that don't break and memories that always make the characters smile. We see two sides of the same coin. We get confused on which side is good after a few chapters.

I gotta say, we won't ever see that in One Piece, Fairy tail or Naruto. Only 2-3 of this kind exist which i have read/watched and they are Code Geass, Attack on Titan and Tokyo Ghoul. 1) It surely would be about this size anyway, everything pretty much went to shit after the whole asspull with Armin

2) Freedom by carelessly killing your own comrades and civilians? demanding sacrifices to reach your goals and kill anyone that opposses you? that's not freedom that's oppression and tyranny.

3) Mediocre when compared to Berserk, seriously go read that and while you are at it go fish out Ushio to Tora.

Isayama doesn't have that credit, Kazuhiro Fujita and Kentaro Miura did it way before him and better.

4)One Piece, Naruto and Fairy tail do know how to handle a cast, they know how to make each pieces do their job, they don't put pieces on the board to make them stand around silent.

That's what Isayama isn't able to do and that's what I am praising them for.

I am not comparing stories. It would be like comparing a Peppa pig cartoon with Avatar the last Airbender.