User blog comment:XGlass Reflection/Episode 5 Review~ DON'T HEADBUTT A LADY!!/@comment-123.231.120.106-20130508170111/@comment-5972544-20130508193425

Please re-read the manga. If I remember correctly, it doesn't state the time Ymir ate their friend, all we can assume is, it was when they were all pre teens (10 to 12). This would make sense considering the fact Berthold and Reiner are two years older than Eren. Say we assume, that their friend was eaten before or during the attack on wall Maria, most likely before, Ymir could've just eaten their friend, for the sake of eating them, like most titans.

Plotholes? Are we reading the same manga? Keeping in mind I've read through it 7 times, I really can't remember, but seeing as there are "too many", could you please list some? I'll fill you in on them.

"C an you name any of the top ongoing or finished action series that remained true to the original plot-line?"

Shingeki no Kyojin, Akame ga Kiru, Btooom!, Baccano!, Fate/Zero, Kuroko no Basuke. I can probably think of more, but my minds going a bit blank, Kaitlyn will tell ya more.