Board Thread:Theories/@comment-44086949-20191210042805/@comment-25933225-20200509101150

What Zeke said about the iceburst stone is nothing but a legend. You can't draw conclusion from a legend, same as it was nearly and evidence that there wasn't litterally a Demon of All Earth that offered Ymir her power (as everything related to it was meant to be seen as a legend, either in the way it is told, or in the way characters interprets it, or the way it was portrayed). You rely too much on Zeke's words (which is contradictory sometimes because Zeke litterally said that we can't change the past in 121, and yet you defend the idea of a non-fixed timeline).

I know that you seems pretty much interested in non-fixed timelines, but here, everything implies that we're in a fixed timeline. And also, if such a thing happens in the story, you might be the one of the very very few that'd enjoy such an ending. Using non-fixed timelines in SnK, especially to "change events from the past" would be such a crappy ending, Yams will certainly not do that. Yeah, he has his flaws regarding the way his story is told, but he remains a good writer, so he won't do that. He's perfectly aware that such an ending would be a major disapointment for nearly the whole fandom, as stories that includes time travel while they were never meant to are very rarely appreciated.