Board Thread:Manga/@comment-5774380-20161007195718/@comment-28833597-20161008224834

CommonSwift wrote: 30325dh wrote:

AhmedHadi1 wrote: I don't think the Warriors were brainwashed and that they practically see themselves as Marleyans by now especially since their families became "honorary Marelyans" after they were chosen as Warriors and their families definitely would have privileges other Eldians in the ghetto don't. True. I suppose they went and attacked still so they can keep that status. Those Eldians are warriors for life and for generations if that's what they have to do to keep themselves and their families from being treated like scum or possibly killed.

Is anyone else feeling like the smiling Titan or Dina wasn't exactly a mindless Titan? I mean, she was digging through the house rubble as if purposefully looking for Carla. That doesn't sound like something the other Titans would do.

Dina must of had a malicious side for killing Carla for no apparent reason and especially for trying to kill two kids, Eren and Mikasa, when none of them ever did anything. And she was supposed to be on the walled Eldians' side? There's something odd going on with her. errrr even if it weren't mindless It would have been impossible for the Smiling titan to know about Grisha's new life in the walls.

I guess we can attribuite Carla's ironic death by her husband ex wife to Isayama's sense of humor...it is kind of funny XD

I've thought about that too. I wouldn't be surprised if we did get an extra flashback about her and how, of she did know, find out.

When I watched the 1st episode for the first time ever, I remember thinking, how did the Titan know Carla was there? Carla was probably out of sight if smiling Titan had to dig around for her. I chalked it up to maybe the smiling Titan and all Titans can smell humans near by. Though, I was still unsatisfied with this answer. But I still accepted it as an answer even with my doubts. I didn't know anything about Titans and shifters then. I was one of those people that watched the anime before I started reading the manga.

If it was either purposeful or coincidental, of course, I don't know for sure. Maybe none of us will ever know for sure. I can see it as remaining unexplained.