Board Thread:Manga/@comment-27125793-20190202152111/@comment-30487274-20190627010426

As for the topic of who is the father, I honestly can’t say with any confidence who it is.

Regardless of parentage, I do think Eren and not Yelena was the cloaked figure who convinced Historia to go back on her promise to the 50 year plan (Yelena managing to convince Historia makes no sense to me). But from there it’s hard to say what happened. The easiest scenario is Eren persuades Historia to secretly join his side, and she just.....picks a random and non suspicious farmer working at her orphanage to impregnate her. It’s a safe and certain way to ensure Eren’s plan works. But honestly? Given how far Eren has been willing to go for Historia’s sake (lying to the military for years just because there was a small chance Historia would be turned into a Titan, outright refusing Zeke’s initial plan because of what it would make Historia do), it just seems.....against Eren’s character to go with a plan that has Historia getting pregnant by a rando she doesn’t even know. Eren stepping up and being the father makes a certain kind of sense with his character, but it also presents a danger to his plan. Eren would know that after he goes rogue, the Corps might try to use Historia and the baby against him, so the two would have to recruit the Farmer into their conspiracy to act as the father. The Farmer would be a potential information leak to their plans, but on the other hand Eren has been setting up a rebel group within the military for a while now (and there seems to be a lot of rebels working for Eren too) so who knows maybe he’d be willing to take the risk?

Hard to say, but I do agree that Eren being the father seems like a twist that Isayama would have (like someone mentioned very game of thrones like lol).