Board Thread:Manga/@comment-5774380-20190607184944/@comment-24407809-20190611072247

CaptFredricks wrote: Penguinluver1431 wrote:

CaptFredricks wrote: Penguinluver1431 wrote:

CaptFredricks wrote: Penguinluver1431 wrote: Falco will likely survive and inherit the Armored Titan from Reiner. Colt might die via Titan food. Realistically, Gabi will either be eaten by Titan Falco or get away to be attacked by Kaya again, but knowing the raging boner Isayama has for Gabi, she'll survive through illogical means like the Mary Sue she is. A Mary Sue is a character that is great at everything they do and is typically better at everything than all the other characters. Gabi is a very flawed character (based on your comments here, I don't think you'd disagree) who has only just awakened from her extensive brainwashing and hopefully can become a better person (if she survives the battle). There is no 'being a better person' for her. She has enough innocent blood on her hands to make her irredeemable. Then by your own standard, nobody in AOT is redeemable at this point. Eren, Mikasa, Armin, Jean, Connie, and everybody else have innocent blood on their hands. I wouldn't consider Marleyans "innocent" by any means. Eren killed many people during Willy Tybur's speech who weren't Marleyans. They all killed Military Police members, of which not all were cold-blooded killers (recall the woman Armin killed to save Jean even though she hesitated). Heck, you could even include the titans in this. Even though the mindless ones attack indiscriminately, they are all humans who were titanized against their will. All of the Scout members have killed their fair share of titans. It's also clear that not all Marleyans are evil overlords, and the battle in Liberio likely contributed to the deaths of quite a few of those soldiers.

Just face it, nobody in this manga (save for maybe Sasha's dad) is innocent going by your standards.

Oh, I just remembered. Eren killed a bunch of the Wall Cult members in his second fight with Annie. Granted, nobody liked them, but did they deserve death?

Meanwhile, Gabi, while far from innocent, hasn't killed nearly as many people as the former Levi Squad has. Not to mention the fact that she killed Sasha shortly after witnessing Sasha and Connie murder numerous Marleyan soldiers, including those two gatekeepers who tried to protect her in the battle despite the fact that they were Marleyan and she was Eldian. Obviously it's extreme, but it makes sense that in such an emotional state she would choose to take revenge. In fact, by killing Sasha she was doing the exact thing that you've criticized Mr. Blouse for not doing when he chose to spare Gabi's life.