Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-25322628-20170113025521/@comment-27363824-20170421221800

Ethan Harmicar123 wrote: GoldoSainoMilo wrote: Didn't Isayama said that Ymir was going to be a key character of the plot later ? Also, it's one of his five favorite character, and she had her titan a little after Reiner. She said she was going to marry Historia, and that she will die soon, so I can see only one way to interprate it. She was talking about the years that were left after the time she was going to die. If it was for an other reason, then the part about her marrying Historia wouldn't make any sense ... She is obviously alive.

People should forget about those claws and other shits like this, the Beast Titan also had a design modification so, everything can happen. I don't think such a character could die offscreen, and I don't know how this theory became so popular that she could be considered as true without any questions by someone. He was talking about REAL ymir. But her impact has already happended I know this seems to be more coherent, but I don't see how he could have make such a mistake and talk about the real Ymir when he should have been talking about the Ymir we know.

Erdagon wrote: I'm pretty damn sure she's dead, because she should be dead by now. I don't hate her but when someone is about to die, then they must die. That is number 1 rule in SnK

Plus instead of marrying Historia, there's no other things left for her, why would she still be alive then? Armin isn't dead, Sasha isn't dead, Hansi isn't dead. Livai isn't dead. Reiner NEVER dies. Yet, they should have died, at least once ( Livai when he ran out of blades, Hansi with the colossal explosion, Sasha against the armoured, Armin obviously, and Reiner : EVERYTIME ). I can't help but laugh here, because "number 1 rule in SnK" is the thing I way saying before about all of this sacrifice and victory win before Armin was saved by Livai. There are no rules in a manga ... Just the author will.

She has an interest, as she has lived in a different period than Reiner and Bertoltd. When she appears, she is also useful for the way the author write the dialogues ( and that's important ). Why is Connie alive when he could have been burned by the Colossal / killed against the secret police ? He is useless after all. Same for Jean. And Sasha. Hansi didn't much more interest than Erd, Mike and the other since the beginning. Reiner could have revealed everything a long time ago, and Bertoltd who is in the same boat as him died. Like I said, no rules.

Erdagon wrote: GoldoSainoMilo wrote:

I don't think such a character could die offscreen. Marco died off screen, then after tons of chapters we finally know how he died. It could just be the same with Ymir's Marco is nowhere as important as Ymir is ... I said SUCH. You don't kill a character that has gone through 60 chapters and was extremely important during the currently adapted arc just like that. Marco was Jean's cheerleader, that's all.



My point is, you can't say that she is dead for sure when there is no way you can know, it's just a theory.

I can also say that Mikasa died after the ellipse because she stopped to eat enough just because we saw her do so before the timeskip, but I can't say that FOR SURE.