Board Thread:Manga/@comment-27321453-20180608184740/@comment-1037137-20180616023210

Sorry, but I do not agree with you, I feel Ymir was a horrible waste. I think so much was lost between both girls on what could've been done with them, and I am not a fan of the notion that just because the author just those particular moments for them to die that they were "used up". That's a philosophy I do not believe in. And if it's partially fueled by personal bias, I do not believe that's a terrible thing, but it's also fueled by what I have seen from both and what myself and certainly others may have also expected from both. I do not resign myself to what this author, or what any author if we wanna talk on more base terms, chooses to do in the end as far as ending one character's arc. I think any number of characters, no single character, could've easily filled in Ymir's role with no major difference in the flow of the story. And I'm not seeing why that's a far-fetched notion. Limiting Ymir to Historia was in my opinion, an unfortunate call. Her death, in my opinion, invalidated herself. We obviously have very different perceptions on what is "good" writing. All I can say is I am not content to resign myself to what the author does, and he won't be the last author who's methods I must criticize. Ymir, the Jaw Titan, should've done so much more as a Shifter and as the falsified goddess she was molded into. In my opinion, I don't see what weight any of it carries in the end. That is my take on her, and I am going to step back content in my disagreement over the fates and the carried potential of both women. We're gonna have to disagree and leave it at that.