Board Thread:Manga/@comment-27125793-20190202152111/@comment-34870059-20190312095535

Cheng The Nerd wrote: LanceSennin wrote: I think he is by now. The Farmer boy is a red herring caused by Isayama to fool the fans. He is a huge GOT fan, and has stated that Game of Thrones might shape his work from now on. And everybody who watches GOT knows there's a lot of secret baby daddy reveals there, so this would be Isayama paying homage to it. Plus, I don't think Eren would want a guy who threw rocks at Historia be the father.

One of Eren's goals until this point is to protect Historia, so having to make a little sacrifice by making her pregnant would lead to their eventual victory. He has a plan, and it would eventually save them all in the end. Yeah. these two had been through so much together and it's really interesting how Eren got close to her, possibly closer that he ever was with Mikasa.

I used to be an EreMika shipper but it died down when I got frustrated with the lack of Mikasa's character. Eren telling Historia he liked her real self made me look out for a possible ship between them and the crystal cave scene made it my new official ship. And yeah, it's crazy to think that Isayama made their relationship deeper and deeper without going into the romance trope for the fans.

One other proof is that History repeats itself in the AOT world. If it is "Ymir Fritz taking from the fruit from the devil", then it would be Eren and Historia in general. Historia is Ymir's descendant, the fruit is the child she had, while Eren is the devil (since Eldians have been referred to as Hellspawns).