Board Thread:Manga/@comment-30064439-20161113032209/@comment-35884158-20180709122808

think there's a high chance the baby is Eren's after reading the official release, although the rough translation initially carried my doubts. I do agree that since Eren opposed the idea of Historia becoming a baby breeder and a sacrifice (thus dooming the rest of her descendants), that it seems unlikely that he'd be the father of her child, but I think it could happen. Here's why: I could be wrong but I actually think Eren knew before he left that Historia was already with child. Based off the manga, it appears that Historia is far along in pregnancy. Probably 6-8 months. I don't believe it's been stated in the manga yet just how long Eren was over in Marley, but if it was only for a few months, this would make him a potential candidate for who impregnanted Historia. Furthermore, when Hange says "I was sure that you wouldn't have to sacrifice Historia." Why does she tell Eren "you"? Did he end up giving in to what the Eldians said, at least for the moment, and impregnanted her?

And when Hange says "we still haven't found another way" and when she asks "Do you not care about Historia now" since he potentially endangered the whole island with his actions, well I believe this could imply he did what he had in Marley partially for Historia. I find it interesting that out of everybody back on Paradis, including those in the Survey Corps, that Hange specifically mentions Historia's name. Heck Eren could have cost anyone their lives after his attack if another nation decided to go against them after Marley's events. Mikasa, Armin, etc. But no, she says Historia. I think she realized that Eren had deep care for Historia, and I think she realizes this after he defends her in the meeting room, when the mangaka pans in on Hange staring sideways at Eren.

Then we see his reaction to what she said. Instead of out right answering her, he bascially says they can't do anything about it and challenges their ability to kill/keep captive him or his brother. He is outraged, completely acting beside his self. Now I have seen this scene interpreted ways; he mentioned his ability to escape because he wantes to see someone and have something done about his capture of the WarHammer Titan. The two people he could have wanted to see could be either Zeke (for another option or maybe a secret plan that only he and Eren know about) OR Historia, if her child is in fact his. He is basically a worried parent.

I think the second choice, although debatable, could be likely since Historia seems to be kept out in a remote location right now, out in the woods, while Eren is being held in a jail cell (though obviously this could just be because he acted outside of orders).

I also think it was foreshadowing of Eren getting Historia pregnant during ch 89 when he mentions he doesn't want to sacrifice Historia, and then the next page is Krueger telling Grisha he needs to find someone within the walls to love, lest history repeats the same mistakes. Isayama has also been emphasisig the relationship between Eren and Historia recently. Twice now in a row, we've seen Eren stick up for Historia. As the author reveals a positive light to their relationship, you see where Eren's other friendships are slowly starting to be filled with tension, sadness, or disappointment. I think that's interesting.

If Eren is the father, I don't know if it would have been by force or not though. Force would seem more likely, judging on his reaction to Zeke's plan originally. Unless he and Historia had feelings for each other and he unintentionally got her pregnant one night. OR she asked him to be the father since he is her friend and she'd rather be with him than a complete stranger.

I could be wrong though. It could have been a complete stranger chosen by the military. That makes perfect sense too. However I don't think it was Zeke.