User blog comment:Heir of Revan/Movie vs Anime vs Manga/@comment-24036697-20161016183003

Well, the anime follows the manga pretty closely story wise, so I'd say they're neck and neck there, but the live action sucked in my opinion (only saw part 1). Visuals, I'd say anime. Best suspense... manga and anime I guess... (again they are pretty close on story elements). As for the characters, they are also pretty much the same in both the manga and the anime.

So... let's see:
 * Anime - 5 (wins only because visuals are much easier to capture on screen than on paper)
 * Manga - 4
 * Movies - 0