Board Thread:Manga/@comment-151.231.104.172-20150824001325/@comment-41.141.42.21-20160204194941

Guys listen, Ymir being dead make no sense, Absolutely no sense, Not only would it be terrible writting and not coherant whit what Ymir stands for; her values, her beliefs, her goals, but it would also be unfair to Historia, Historia knows nothing of Ymir, her real identity, her past, HER LAST NAME. The person that was her biggest support just left like that, without an explanation (HOWVER THAT MOMENT CANT BE BEFORE THEY MEET AGAIN) @Sookey5 #YUMIKURI

Then obviously there are the many many mysteries surronding Ymir. How could all of that be explained if Ymir doesn't do it herself. As far as we know, Ymir could very well be the last person left of her people, moreover, she's 77 years old, how many people are still that are around that age, and were close to her that they would be able to tell her story. Ok, you get my point.

Also no charcter deserves such an end being killed off screen, without having heard any news of them for over 2 years, 30 chapters. It's something I don't think Isayama would do, Especially ABOUT A CHARCTER HE'S SAID THAT WAS HIS FAVORITE AND EVEN ENJOYED WRITING.

Now reiner mentioning the promise doesn't confirm anything. As going by her name alone, Ymir-sama, Ymir must be valuable piece I doubt as soon as she got to RBA's village.

Titan appeared 112 years ago..and Ymir turned into a titan 60 years ago soo.. There were survivors living outside the wall...

'''Ymir used to live outside of the wall maybe the daughter of a mayor or king someone important. Ymir said :  '''"I used to be like that to krista thinking that It'd've been better if i had never been born I was hated for the simple fact of my existance in this world and I died for the happiness of a great many people..." so she was somoene who everyone hated, the doughter of a mayor or a king who everyone hated...

'''Then came a group of people and turned them into titans to try to make a biological weapon(humans who can at will turn into titans). evryone in her town turned into those stupid titans and only she succeeded. Using her powers she fled until she encouternd the city eren lives in. She never told anyone cause who would believe her? they would probably think she was just some hobo kid making up a story for money. So she hid in the city until she heard about christa. '''

''' Now the reason that titan called isle Ymir sama i I think because he was once one of the humans that served Ymir and Isle looks a litle like her(just coincidence). '''

'''That titan was the only one who didn't hate Ymir.. '''

'''Well this is my theory.. '''