Thread:Theend3/@comment-1327106-20170924011720/@comment-32409015-20170924144959

Hi RuneLai

Yes, I agree that Erwin's military tactics are  fanatic and very dangerous ones for the safety of his own men and that he is even sometimes very cynical. I think that he has some responsibility for the 60 Survey Corps members and MPs deaths which occured during Clash of Titans Arc. So, I propose to mention a reference about that on his page in "people killed". Do you agree?

Also, it seems to me that Erwin had legitimate military concerns to get back Eren Yaeger. I mean: Erwin Smith needed Eren Yaeger to plug another possible hole if for example Bertolt created later a new one. If Erwin cannot plug holes, then there would be many civilians and military Waldians who would be eaten by Titans later because I don't think that the Warriors would stop to attack the Walls. Thus, someone has to take responsability for all the deaths who occured before Bertolt let Eren to escape and I personnaly don't put all the blame on Erwin Smith for all those deaths. Furthermore, if Reiner and Bertolt hadn't kidnaped Eren, there would have been 0 Survey Corps members and MPs deaths, so I think that Reiner has some responsability too.

Also, concerning the Survey Corps members who were killed after Reiner tossed Titans on Eren, I saw one on chapter 50 page 16 and another one on chapter 50 page 22. Thus, I can mention "At least 2 Survey Corps members" in "indirectly killed" if you agree. Also, can I mention Armin Arlert in "failed attempt", since Armin would have died in chapter 50 page 22 if Eren hadn't used the Coordinate?

Also, I don't understand why, on one hand Reiner is considered to have 0% responsability for all the deaths who occured before Bertolt lets Eren to escape, and on the other hand Annie Leonhardt is considered to have 100% responsability for all the 16 Survey Corps members that she killed during the Female Titan Arc, you can see it on her page in "people killed". It seems to me that there is incoherence. I mean: I know that she directly killed those 16 soldiers, and that Reiner never directly killed a soldier during Clash of Titan Arc. But Erwin and Levi also used  dangerous and very cynical tactics during the Female Titan Arc. They deliberately didn't say to most of their own men that the Female Titan wasn't an ordinary Titan. As Eren said in chapter 27 page 14, "there had to be some who wouldn't have died if they'd known that the (Female) Titan was intelligent...".

Also, I propose to mention a reference about what Eren said above on Erwin Smith and Levi 's pages in "people killed". Do you agree?