User blog comment:Eddienam/Chapter 53 mystery/@comment-190.212.92.223-20140110043145/@comment-7418318-20140114112312

Also if Eren had remembered eating his father, I think we'd have seen a quite different reaction, rather than him wondering where he might be now.

And if he didn't remember eating his father, then he wouldn't remember a sentence with just the "eaten" missing either...