Talk:Levi Ackerman

Stats
Please include the stats for Levi.Vanihba2000 (talk) 00:59, July 1, 2013 (UTC)

Stuff
Allow me to write my thoughts on certain aspects of this manga/anime. I can bring in a few insights of mine to flourish this wikia. Thanks. Zubsz (talk) 18:06, July 2, 2013 (UTC)


 * Hi, if I understand, you want to post some kind of a review? In that case, feel free to make a blog for that ^^ 18:16, July 2, 2013 (UTC)


 * No but i want to help out with what you're doing. if i can be of any help that is. Zubsz (talk) 18:25, July 2, 2013 (UTC)


 * Ahh I see. ^_^ Well, anyone is free to edit as long as the information added to the articles is written well enough and its source is either anime or manga, in other words, no speculations or even fanfics should be added. 18:40, July 2, 2013 (UTC)

Name Origin

 * It says that "Levi" is a Hebrew name of "disputed origin" and that it means "He who joins".  First of all, "Levi" is not of "disputed origin" - it is very clearly the name of Jacob's 3rd son in the Bible (Book of Genesis) and is a very traditional Hebrew name.  Although "He who joins" is not a completely inaccurate translation, it is better translated as "The Accompanied", from the Hebrew word מלווה, to accompany or to escort.  The Biblical origin of the name is because Levi's mother, Leah, states that this 3rd son will accompany (or join with) her other two sons, Reuben and Simeon.   Notably, Simeon and Levi (when paired) were considered an unstoppable military force, as they together wiped out the people of Shechem after they raped the brothers' sister Dina - so ascribing the name Levi to the character may be subtle reference to his military prowess, where Commander Irwin serves the analagous partner to the Biblical Levi's brother Simeon.
 * -Nathan J Xaxson
 * 115.114.27.211 06:56, September 1, 2013 (UTC)

Video of Episode 22 fight between Female Titan and Levi
Could you please put the video where Levi attacks the Female Titan? It is considered the best fight scene. I really appreciate it.Jennicious (talk) 03:41, September 10, 2013 (UTC)

Captain vs Lance Corporal
I've been bugged by this mix of title-naming with Levi due to the vastly differing rank of Captain vs Lance Corporal. As such, I have since bothered to look up the differences and possible reasoning for either translation. After a long search, I've come to the conclusion that Lance Corporal could very well have been a minor mistranslation. I managed to find a blog post concerning this that breaks it down and why Captain is possibly the more accurate title for Levi: click here the link What do you guys think? It seems pretty spot-on, and while some may argue that using "Lance Corporal" makes sense due to SNK being of Japanese origin, one could also argue that the very nature and camaraderie shared by Squad Levi reflects the same medieval inspiration as outlined by the blog post, and as such, makes for a convincing argument for the use of the term "Captain". DementedP (talk) 04:58, September 10, 2013 (UTC)


 * Having read that previously, a point that they make is that he is a "Captain" because "Corporal" is a low rank, which would mean Hanji at the very least would outrank him, as a "Major". However, official sources state that he outranks her.


 * But, a "Captain" is still outranked by a "Major", so, really, that doesn't change anything.


 * Secondly, The Kanji used to refer to Levi is "兵長", which is a rank equivalent to "Lance Corporal".


 * Thirdly, it's always possible that Isayama is just making things up however he likes for any number of reasons. (Maybe he thinks Lance Corporal sounds cooler than Captain? Who knows.)


 * And lastly, it /is/ a work of fantasy. Giant Titans? Humans transforming into titans? There is a great deal of artistic license in terms of being realistic there.


 * As for which to use... I suppose, use whatever the official translation uses, and try to be consistant everywhere.


 * Though, personally, I do prefer 'Corporal'. (Sounds better, at least to me) Felix*Pillow (talk) 13:24, September 23, 2013 (UTC)


 * Actually your point just proves what I'm trying to say. Crunchyroll's English subs have just opted to call Hanji a "Squad Leader" to avoid any of the misconceptions to be had with the title-naming. Again you're forgetting that Levi's title (not rank, "title") isn't "heichou"  it's "heishichou", the fact that heichou is described as a nickname that is used by his group shows how it isn't a rank at all. Also again, Corporal and Lance Corporal are two completely different ranks altogether, and the interchanging use between the two is probably an oversight by shoddy translations of the manga. Also who said anything about SNK not being a fantasy? I don't see how that's relevant to what I'm saying at all. I'm just talking about the use of various terms and how it should/could be translated into English. No more, no less. DementedP (talk) 18:44, September 23, 2013 (UTC)
 * Heiseichou is used in a formal setting where he is 'rank' is to be used, something like 'Leader of the Soliders', and indeed Heichou is what his subordinates call him. But as you said, since the former isn't actually a rank and isn't oft used, the latter has been taken as his 'rank' by various translators, most likely.
 * And, really? CR is the shining, stunning example of translations, I suppose.
 * Well, no-one said it wasn't a fantasy. What I was trying to say was, that, as a fantasy, not everything is going to be realistic. Ranks and anything else in there could just be completely made up and be done however Isayama pleases. Felix*Pillow (talk) 04:15, September 24, 2013 (UTC)

Abilities
Could you please add a video where Levi vs Female Titan in Episode 22: The Defeated?209.129.168.31 16:42, September 19, 2013 (UTC)

Relationship
I have a question. Is Levi going have his own section on Relationship?Jennicious (talk) 21:10, October 29, 2013 (UTC) What?  h fc 2 X  22:28, October 29, 2013 (UTC)

Most of the character have a relationship section like Mikasa, Armin, Jean, Eren, Pretra, & etc.Jennicious (talk) 01:39, October 30, 2013 (UTC)
 * Well, you can add it if you want. I don't think you're blocked, so I see no reason why you aren't editing articles already.  h fc 2 X  08:23, October 30, 2013 (UTC)

I was wondering if somebody could elaborate more on his relationship with Erwin. Not in the shipper kinda elaborate but it leaves out a lot of canon facts about their relationship. The Eren one is pretty accurate though. Anonoderp (talk) anonoderp

Spin-Off
I may have missed the discussion, but has any decision been made concerning the material from the "Choice with No Regrets" spin-off? Are we considering that canon material to be included in the profiles of the pre-existing cast (Levi, Erwin, Mike, Hange)?

Harostar (talk) 11:03, December 14, 2013 (UTC)

I suggest adding 'Appearances in other medias' section at the bottom of the article(s). 11:57, December 14, 2013 (UTC)


 * I'm working on this!! Please be patient :(  h fc 2 X  18:21, December 14, 2013 (UTC)

Stats edit
Wouldn't a cleanliness 11/10 be more apropriate?
 * "More appropriate"? Sure, bro, we're making up these stats to what we deem more "appropriate". We don't use official sources at all.  h fc 2 X  02:58, January 2, 2014 (UTC)

Comparisons
You know, not for nothing, but I looked everywhere on this site, and nowhere does it say that comparisons to other series can't be made. Not only that, but the edit I had made was to the trivia section of the article, which is comprised of little tidbits that would otherwise be considered irrelevant. Prime example, the little bit about his motif being based on Rorscach from Watchmen. That's not something you would put outside the trivia section. Likewise with my comparison between Levi and Trafalgar Law.

As for Ymir having similarities with Ace, I fail to see them, and not through lack of any attempt at observation neither. However, that's not related to Levi in any way, shape, or form, which is why I wouldn't put that in an article that talks about him. In short, I only talk about stuff in articles, or add things, if I see at least some relevance for any particular section. I ain't gonna be the guy who vandalizes the Wikipedia article on George Patton, making fun of him by adding to the first paragraph of his history, "where he was crowned king of farts." That's just plain stupid. Virsteinn (talk) 10:30, March 6, 2014 (UTC)

We simply don't do that, it's considered junk trivia. We could sit here all day talking about how one character resembles another, but in the end, it's just subjective opinion and as such, doesn't belong to a wikia article, an article that is supposed to be made of clear facts. 11:36, March 6, 2014 (UTC)


 * Not to mention "the little bit about his motif" being mentioned by the author himself is what makes it relevant. Not that we came up with that comparison, and even that part needs to be referenced.  h fc 2 X  13:44, March 6, 2014 (UTC)

That's all well and good, but then you have that part about the origins of his name. That can also be considered subjective opinion because while that may or may not be what his name means, people that agree with it will find different ways to say the same thing, and in the end, it's just plain confusing. For example, my real name also came from Hebrew, and for the longest time, I thought it meant, "boy of God." Now, as it turns out, it doesn't, and I have yet to find its true meaning. Virsteinn (talk) 00:19, March 7, 2014 (UTC)

As for his Seiyū, that part could be left in because that is a clear fact. It could also be expanded to include other series than just the one I mentioned. It'd be like if I were to talk about Robert Downey Jr. being in the Brat Pack, while everyone else knows him as Sherlock Holmes and Tony Stark. Virsteinn (talk) 00:23, March 7, 2014 (UTC)
 * The origin of his name's been stated by Isayama himself, that's why you see it in the article. We do not add things that we just "think are okay to add", not even references to other works if they aren't officially stated as facts first. The Rorschach thing is an example, as Isayama himself has stated he somewhat based Levi on him. And sharing a voice actor (did you know that the word "seiyū" is originally a derogatory term?) isn't anything notable, or we would have included in Ymir's article that she shares voice actor with Hatsune Miku or Eren's voice is also the voice of multiple anime perverts. It's not relevant at all to the SnK universe, nor means anything to the character itself.  h fc 2 X  01:42, March 7, 2014 (UTC)

Well, perhaps the trivia policy (which really should be written out) is different from the other wikis that I've been to. For example, I go onto the One Piece wiki, and on their article about a specific "Devil Fruit" ability, in its trivia section, it says, and I quote, "This Devil Fruit power is reminiscent in appearance and effect to the Mouth Energy Waves used by certain characters in the Dragon Ball series." Like with my contribution to the article here about Levi sharing similarities in design and personality, as well as a Seiyū, with Trafalgar Law, that part of the One Piece wiki article means nothing to the ability itself.

Now, through a little more effort than just a surface glance at one article, I could probably generate a list both on the One Piece wiki and off it of similar instances of content that is neither relevant to the particular universe whatever wiki is dedicated to nor of any meaning to the article's item itself. My point is, if a rule, like this one, isn't written, it's not worth trying to enforce. I'm sure they have similar rules over there, and yet that part about that ability being reminiscent to another ability from a completely different series is still there.

You might ask, "Well, do you have any proof that the mangaka hasn't explicitly pointed out that similarity?" The answer to that is, in this case, that I do. I have read all of Eiichiro Oda's words, all of his SBS issues, everything, and not once did he reference Dragon Ball. He's done crossovers, but that's different. As for the list, assuming I make one, I wouldn't put items in it if I didn't have any information pertaining to the mangaka's official quotes. Virsteinn (talk) 07:30, March 7, 2014 (UTC)