User blog comment:Gourgeist/Who Is The Beast Titan?/@comment-86.108.33.32-20141005025910/@comment-5433366-20141008060543

I agree completely. I always thought (and later dug into and pretty much confirmed) that people only theorize who the Beast Titan could be because they want some kind of thrill for a currently lacking arc. Nothing in the world to support any kind of claim, that's why I ended my post basically saying that the Beast Titan is something new.