Board Thread:Manga/@comment-27441457-20170908192139/@comment-28958062-20170918082007

Dreiko Rokun wrote: CommonSwift wrote: Dreiko Rokun wrote: CommonSwift wrote: Surprise Kenny is appreciated

I swear If AnniexKenny fics appear I will throw up...I already feel the urge at the trought.

Did Annie steal Mina's clothes? o,o

Reiner's excuse for destroying Trost doesn't add up...I mean even if Annie was compromised they could just have her joining the survey corps and fake her death while they could have gone to the Military Police and do the undercover work.

Actually I believe they could have sneakly killed all the wall titans with the gear and came back to Marley with that result.

Hell Reiner and Berthold could have just supplied Annie with gas and blades from the Military police and she could have spent all day long killing the wall Titans...

The question is would the Wall break if one of the Titans inside were to die? I mean it's not like their bodies actually have weight so it should hold up? I need a Sheldon Coooper... That's impossible, to being with, they would need to destroy parts of the walls to get inside and kill the collosal titans, that alone will bring a lot of attention to them as they will need to transform into titans in order to break parts of the walls.

Second, they would have to kill them during the night as sunligth will awake them, third, the walls extend for thousands of kilometers, they are completley filled with titans and there's three of them, and by that point of the story, wall Maria was full of mindless titans, so not only it would have been dangerous to go back to the first wall, but bringing supplies would have been imposible, even if they focused on only killing the titans in the Rose and Sinna walls, something as valuable as blades and gas, especially during that moment of the story, would have been under high security, so no, sneakily killing the titans inside the walls (if they even knew the collosal titans were inside the walls to being with) was never an option. Finally that's what I was waiting for! :)

I thought that was possible because Reiner sneakly hid inside the wall during the return to Shiganshina arc without waking up any wall titans.

The Female Titan is faster then any mindeless titan so I don't think it would be a problem to her to reach Shiganshina for example.

They could get gas and blades from the abandoned cities of Wall Maria, the cities near the gates must be full of equipment, also the Military police is know for selling equipment to the black market so I don't think they could notice.

The really big question is if the walls would break down if the Wall titans are killed, would they even dissolve if they are not directly into the sunlight? Sorry for the late replay, i had a busy week.

Actually, i'm still wondering how exactly did Reiner hid inside the wall without awakening the titan, i don't even remember if there was a titan at all, but if i'm not mistaken, the garrisons do some sorth of wall manteniance so maybe he was inside of one of the "layers", so to speak, of the walls, in other words, he wasn't deep were the titan is, but that just my theory.

You have to remember, they are still human, so they get tired of using their titan powers, plus, Shiganshina was overrun by titans, so not only would they have to kill the titans on their way to Shiganshina, but also get rid of the ones that are still coming from the shore, since Marley was still transforming people into mindless titans.

Let's not forget, they still need to eat and sleep, plus, they didn't lived inside the walls so they don't know anything about the Shiganshina district and were the supplies could be, also, they didn't have any money, so the black market is out of the question since probably any equipment related to the military police would cost a fortune, plus they don't have any contacts to negotiate or anything like that.

Even if there were some supplies left in Shiganshina, it wouldn't be enough to kill enough collosal titans to consider it a "successful" mision, the walls are long, and there's three. I really don't think that plan would have worked at all, not with so little preparation and with so much at stake.

You are actually right, it would be a fool's quest and it's probably impossible to execute at that point of time.

However I would have liked either Annie or Berthold to suggest an alternative to Reiner's plan like last chapter which also leads me to another question, what changed?

I mean Reiner had raised some good points on why they shouldn't attack the walls again then three years later he just attacks the walls anyway?

That's so weird considering him and Berthold could have just inflitated the Military Police themselves while Annie could have just gone to Survey Corps to keep an eye on them,it's not like she wouldn't be competent enough to survive the expeditions.